Anime List

I think I have watched enough animes in the past 6 years to finally construct some sort of list. I have to admit my list is probably biased towards the newer animes.

Best Romance
1) Clannad After Story - Tomoya & Nagisa
2) Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicles - Sakura & Syaoran
3) ef~A Tale of Memories
4) Ayashi no Ceres - Tooya & Aya

Clannad After Story - Tomoya & Nagisa

Best Humour (Laugh till I need CPR session...)
1) Fumoffu!
2) Ouran High School Host Club
3) Fruits Basket

Entertaining Physical Smackdown (without mechas)
1) Tsubasa Tokyo Revelations Ep 1- Shaoran & Kurogane vs Kamui
2) Sword of a Stranger
3) Claymore - Teresa vs Priscilla, Irene, Sophia and Noel

Most Convoluted Storyline with Astounding Number of Plot Twists
1) Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicles (Toyko Revelations, Shunraiki) & xxxHolic
2) Code Geass R2
3) Kurogane no Linebarrels

Most Spunky Female Heroine (under the age of 16)
1) Kure-nai - Kuhouin Murasaki
2) Shion no Ou - Yasuoka Shion
3) Hatenkou Yugi - Rahzel Anadis

Super Cool Dudes I Salivate Over
1) Kuroshitsuji - Sebastian Michaels
2) Gundam 00 - Setsuna F. Seiei, Lockon Stratos
3) Nabari no Ou - Yoite
4) Blood+ - Hagi
5) Vampire Knight - Kiryuu Zero, Kuran Kaname
6) Junjou Romantica - Usami Akihiko

Most Whiny or Spineless or Indecisive Male Leads (somebody shoot them!!...)
1) Kurogane no Linebarrels - Kouichi Hayase
2) Noein - Goto Yu
3) Gunparade March - Atsushi Hayami
*for the record by the end of the anime, I usually don't feel so suicidal having to watch them

Most Pathetic Utter Garbage Anime
1) Gungrave
2) Weiz Kruz Gluhen
3) Mien Lieden
4) Sousei no Aquarion (but songs were good)

Ugliest Looking Girls in Anime
1) Flame of Recca